Why Dumbledore Can't Move Against Grindelwald | Fantastic Beasts Theory

  • تم نشره في 2018/10/12
  • SCB Orlando Meet-Up! Presale :: www.patreon.com/SuperCarlinBrothers
    Today Ben dives into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter to discuss Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald and try and determine why Dumbledore can’t move against Grindelwald and instead needs Newt to do it for him
    Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► bit.ly/2oDIxOL
    J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
    Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
    Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ arclip.net/user/SuperCarlinBrothers
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    V L O G➜ arclip.net/user/jonathancarlin
    T W I T T E R➜ twitter.com/jonkerlin & twitter.com/SCB_Ben
    I N S T A G R A M➜ instagram.com/jonkerlin & instagram.com/scb_ben
    F A C E B O O K➜ facebook.com/supercarlinbrothers
    G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
    P A T R E O N ➜ www.patreon.com/SuperCarlinBrothers
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Want to send us something?
    Super Carlin Brothers
    PO Box 4339
    Roanoke, Virginia 24015
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)

تعليقات • 3 042

  • SuperCarlinBrothers
    SuperCarlinBrothers  6 أشهر قبل +311

    We hope to see you in Orlando!!!

    • cltds
      cltds 21 أيام قبل

      Please do something in Ontario or canada

    • Shawn Heath
      Shawn Heath أشهر قبل

      I just had an idea, maby you've already talked about it I just haven seen it . What if they made a brother to the elder wand so they could use the incantatem to bring out a ghost or to somehow make the Infinity stone I mean Resurrection stone

    • Ado Ninja
      Ado Ninja 2 أشهر قبل

      Holly Hunter sane I live in the UK too

    • Sour Lemon Animations
      Sour Lemon Animations 3 أشهر قبل

      I wish I could have gone 🥺

    • Sivarani Selvarajah
      Sivarani Selvarajah 4 أشهر قبل

      I wish I wasn't too late for this

  • Sparkly Spencer
    Sparkly Spencer 2 أيام قبل

    I didn't watch this theory until after Crimes of Grindelwald, BUT, I still think there could be something to this, although, it is most likely one of the remaining Peverell Brothers's wands, rather than a wand forged from Death itself, literally a brother wand (maybe there is two). More than one reason to keep Dumbledore from fighting seems like a more realistic approach than a simple (or not so simple) Blood Pact.

  • Jake McSweeney
    Jake McSweeney 4 أيام قبل

    They could have just changed the wand

  • The gaming T
    The gaming T 6 أيام قبل

    Blood pact?

  • Sonia Ndukwe
    Sonia Ndukwe 11 أيام قبل

    Grindlewad is the good guy and dumbledore is the bad guy. Since he bred Harry for death, I’ve been giving him the side eye

  • Amphibian Picnic
    Amphibian Picnic 14 أيام قبل

    It’s because of the blood filled necklace

  • Krillbilly
    Krillbilly 15 أيام قبل

    Its not about that it mightve been Albus who killed his sister but his fear is about losing control of his power again and potentially hurt an innocent

  • Veritas Aequitas
    Veritas Aequitas 17 أيام قبل

    Are they lovers?! 😳

  • James R Peters
    James R Peters 19 أيام قبل

    They made a blood pact to never duel each other.

  • Dylan Ruby
    Dylan Ruby 20 أيام قبل +1

    They made a Blood-pact when they were gay lovers.
    I know it was the 20s, but you would think a super genius wizard would know that intravenous blood sharing between homosexuals probably isn't a good idea.

  • Moana of Motunui
    Moana of Motunui 23 أيام قبل

    Who is that villain I see? Staring straight back at me?

  • Jared Thompson
    Jared Thompson 24 أيام قبل

    Now that JK's brought it up in the special features interview, we can safely say that Dumbledore won't go after him because Albus is a bottom and Grindelwald will tattle on him if he goes to jail.

  • NAV
    NAV 25 أيام قبل

    Gay dumbledore was retconned in for sjw points by rowling and was not needed or wanted change my mind

  • DragonNinja 365
    DragonNinja 365 26 أيام قبل

    The mirror thing isn't because he loves him, it's that he wants to fight him but can't. He sees the blood oath locket in the mirror, that is what he wants.

  • Lewis Barrett
    Lewis Barrett 27 أيام قبل

    Because of the blood plantent

  • Hazel Mullard-Evans
    Hazel Mullard-Evans 28 أيام قبل

    He could be using his father's old wand when they had the fight as his father was sent to Azkaban

  • L3gi0nS 4ng3l
    L3gi0nS 4ng3l أشهر قبل

    Has anyone even explained why Potter Wizards need wands? To me I think it would be a vulnerability.

  • Life is Strange B4 the storm

    Nagini is very attractive

  • Kaleah Collins
    Kaleah Collins أشهر قبل

    Dumbledore and Grindolwald are ☯ two sides of the same coin. Dumbledore couldve been Grindolwald .

  • Khitwel Alano
    Khitwel Alano أشهر قبل

    very good

  • Aber Bron
    Aber Bron أشهر قبل

    That’s not the reason why, but still a good theory

  • isaac Rodriguez
    isaac Rodriguez أشهر قبل


    the reason they cant fight is they made a blood pact good guesses though

  • mr. yaint
    mr. yaint أشهر قبل

    Priori Icantatem also happened between the Elderwand and Draco's wand. (Harry vs Voldemort). Does that mean the brother wand of the Elderwand is Draco's wand?

    • mr. yaint
      mr. yaint 2 أيام قبل

      +Sparkly Spencer it's been said they in the video

    • Sparkly Spencer
      Sparkly Spencer 2 أيام قبل

      I don't think that is a thing...

  • Savitar God of speed
    Savitar God of speed أشهر قبل

    What would we call this “other elder wand”

  • james Quinton
    james Quinton أشهر قبل

    Dumbeldore and Grindelwald have a blood pact

  • jb888888888
    jb888888888 أشهر قبل

    12:02 / is a slash. \ is a backslash. Learn the difference.
    Closed Captioning at that point is amusing too.

  • jb888888888
    jb888888888 أشهر قبل

    Grindlewald is in the mirror presenting Dumbledore with a fresh pair of socks.

  • jonny blyan
    jonny blyan أشهر قبل

    He can’t move against him cuz of the blood curse they made on eachother to not move against each other anyone who knows anything grindlewalt was the owner of the elder wand before and dumbledore won the wand from him after there is only one elder wand

  • Abhiram Dasika
    Abhiram Dasika أشهر قبل

    Honestly, I prefer this theory to the Blood Pact thing they have now introduced as a new thing...

  • Damon Richter
    Damon Richter أشهر قبل

    He told. It to Harry, he doesn't want to get him involved till he absolutely had to,

  • David Whitford
    David Whitford أشهر قبل

    I think his patronus during the movies ... would be a niffler....

  • Hamza Rehman
    Hamza Rehman أشهر قبل

    You fool. Dumbledore and grindelwald ,promised that they won't fight each other when they were kids

  • Luke Betlow
    Luke Betlow أشهر قبل

    Hey guys!
    Does anyone know if a wizard could dual-wield a wand? Like, say I’m using two wands and I say, “CRUCIO!” Would it release a double power wand or would it just be normal? And if it was possible, would there be a necessary process? Like splitting your soul like a horcrux? -please get back to me
    -Your BIGGEST fan

  • MattDa Gamer
    MattDa Gamer أشهر قبل

    Nah its a sista

  • John Patrick Mapa
    John Patrick Mapa أشهر قبل

    You couldn’t be more wrong.

  • my name don't matter
    my name don't matter أشهر قبل

    Maybe because he formed a blood pact with grindelwald stating that they wont fight with each other?

  • BossMan Gameplays
    BossMan Gameplays أشهر قبل

    It’s a blood pact that they both made that’s why they can’t attack each other

  • Antony
    Antony أشهر قبل

    The truth is that Dumbledore didn't want to fight Grindelwald because he was still in love with him.

  • John kimbrough
    John kimbrough أشهر قبل

    Priori Encantatum came to mind when I first read the Kong’s cross scene in DH. I just didn’t have the info you do.

  • romu desu
    romu desu أشهر قبل

    have you guys noticed the wand used by Dumbledore in the "blood pact" scene? i was thinking maybe it was the wand mentioned in the video and the same wand we've seen Dumbledore was holding in the first FB: COG poster...the resemblance is quite uncanny.

  • Carson Konecny
    Carson Konecny 2 أشهر قبل

    So who killed Ariana- Albus or Grindlewald

  • Donnie Jomon Koikara
    Donnie Jomon Koikara 2 أشهر قبل +1

    Now the only question is..... *Has this been confirmed?*
    Likley to be confirmed , i think

  • Rain 201
    Rain 201 2 أشهر قبل

    The reason why dumbledore can’t go against grindevalt because he has the elder wand

  • Ande Boy
    Ande Boy 2 أشهر قبل

    It's because dumbledore and grindelwald did the unbreakable thing så if they break it they die...

  • Kilian Bühring
    Kilian Bühring 2 أشهر قبل

    This is the most stupide theorie ever.

  • theacp127
    theacp127 2 أشهر قبل

    Dumbledore? More like Yumbledore Dumbledaddy amirite?

  • Valerie Langer
    Valerie Langer 2 أشهر قبل

    Mind blown

  • Harald Meredith Borregaard-Thomasson

    Albus made a blod deal

  • damian bingham
    damian bingham 2 أشهر قبل

    I hate how Americans butcher language. Its Grindelwald with a V! Grindelvald!

  • Ty O
    Ty O 2 أشهر قبل

    Okay. So when tina and newt restrained grindelwald...it was not the elder wand...it was graves wand...obviously he couldnt carry the elder at the ministry... He had abernaki pick it up with the escape plan.

    • Ty O
      Ty O 2 أشهر قبل

      So the wand didnt ever change allegiance....

  • Morgan Lynn
    Morgan Lynn 2 أشهر قبل

    Great theory but there is some flaws. You don't have do defeat a wizard or use prior incantatum to claim their wand. In the Half-blood Prince it was Draco who disarmed Dumbledore making the elder wand his. We see it again in the Deathly Hallows pt. 1 when Harry does it to Draco at Malfoy Manor making the elder wand Harry's. If Dumbledore was to face Grindelwald he wouldn't need a wand just as powerful if he caught him by surprise or injured Grindelwald when he saw a moment of weakness.

  • Madison Amy
    Madison Amy 2 أشهر قبل +2

    it turns out that Jk rowling changed dumbledores wand becuase it resembled the elder wand too much. it kinda sucks because this is a good theory

  • Luukiegames
    Luukiegames 2 أشهر قبل +2

    Its a f*cking blood pact

  • Goth Girl
    Goth Girl 2 أشهر قبل

    Well we now know it's because of the blood pact

  • Aditya Bairy
    Aditya Bairy 2 أشهر قبل

    Dumbledore doesn't can't fight Grindelwald because he made a blood PACT

  • Ioannis Achilles Melisseus
    Ioannis Achilles Melisseus 2 أشهر قبل


  • saji p j
    saji p j 2 أشهر قبل

    Hey it's really because of the blood patch know??

  • Fatima Yasmin
    Fatima Yasmin 2 أشهر قبل

    Wouldn't Harry's recent spells show in the graveyard

  • Springeta Fazbear
    Springeta Fazbear 2 أشهر قبل

    Does anyone else wonder if the elder wand can be enchanted?

  • Luke Catchings
    Luke Catchings 2 أشهر قبل +1

    Who is watching this in 2019 and knows he is wrong

  • nenelove0412
    nenelove0412 2 أشهر قبل

    i don't know why i never questioned this but how did James Potter ever end up with the invisibility cloak

    • nenelove0412
      nenelove0412 2 أشهر قبل

      +jasmine cheng i watched a theory the other day and apparently according to potter more the peverall's family actually do married into the potter family meaning that the cloak was just passed down to james and that harry is apart of the peverall family witch just makes it fitting that he end up owning all the deathly hallows at one point or another

    • jasmine cheng
      jasmine cheng 2 أشهر قبل +1

      It was passed down through the generations and there was one generation where they ran out of male heirs for the cloak meaning the cloak isn’t a direct “peverall” descendent the same thing would go for the reserection stone for the family gaunt ring.

  • no u
    no u 2 أشهر قبل

    Wait, the brother with the elderwand, he had a wand before he got the elderwand duh, so mabye that is it? The brother wand?

  • i9sixKills
    i9sixKills 2 أشهر قبل

    Bcuz hes gay right?

  • Akram Abdullahi
    Akram Abdullahi 2 أشهر قبل

    Between Grindelwald And Voldermort: Grindelwald doesn't Fear anyone including Dumbledore

  • rizwan ishaq
    rizwan ishaq 2 أشهر قبل


  • Luke Pickup
    Luke Pickup 3 أشهر قبل

    Is Newt Scamander Hagrid s dad

  • Daniel Rodriguez
    Daniel Rodriguez 3 أشهر قبل

    The wand in the posture and the wand ur comparing side to side with the elder are not the same.. stop trying to trick us

  • Shiv Shetty
    Shiv Shetty 3 أشهر قبل

    i just realized harry used accio on the cup in goblet of fire
    how is this possible

  • Jack Drychda
    Jack Drychda 3 أشهر قبل +2

    There is an other way than Priori Incantatum to check the spells launch by a wand. This spell was used on Harry's wand to check if it was the wand who was used to make the Voldemort symbol in the sky at the Qwiditch wold championship.

  • Skullduggery Pleasant
    Skullduggery Pleasant 3 أشهر قبل

    He can't move against grindawald because they formed a blood packtd in there 6th year

  • William Heape
    William Heape 3 أشهر قبل

    How is Newt not the master of the elder sand in the first fantastic beasts cause he defeats persival graves which is grindalvald

  • Atomic Gamer
    Atomic Gamer 3 أشهر قبل

    Guys grindiwald and dumbledore made a blood seal and swore not to fight each other maybe made an unbreakable vow and the ministry put a charm on dumbledore so the ministry can monitor his spells and he got fired from hog warts

  • Zhen Yang Tan
    Zhen Yang Tan 3 أشهر قبل

    HANG ON A SECOND... The Elder wand wouldn't show Ariana if Dumbledore won... Cuz Grindy hadn't got it yet when they duelled... Right?

  • Ben Nar
    Ben Nar 3 أشهر قبل

    0:00 fakken skjut mig bror fick en panikattack

  • Zain Mohamed
    Zain Mohamed 3 أشهر قبل

    I don't really think that the blood pact was to stop them taking arms against each other. Newt thinks that's the reason but Dumbledore doesn't agree, just sort of goes along with it. I believe the blood pact is something completely different and won't be shown until film 4.

  • Frank Tilden
    Frank Tilden 3 أشهر قبل

    Since they were so close, they could have done the unbreakable vow

  • M84JONES !!!
    M84JONES !!! 3 أشهر قبل

    Isn't it just the blood pact

  • Dory, Who Dis?
    Dory, Who Dis? 3 أشهر قبل

    This is an example of where I think that a SuperCarlinBrother theory is much better than the truth

  • Amy Ross
    Amy Ross 3 أشهر قبل

    If you read the screenplay you would know that they made a blood pact

  • Opal Plays
    Opal Plays 3 أشهر قبل

    Wow. JK Rowling really knew the whole story from the start.

  • William Humphrey
    William Humphrey 3 أشهر قبل

    Priori incantatem

  • Rik Cloesen
    Rik Cloesen 3 أشهر قبل

    Priori Incantatem isn't the only way to find out what the last spell from a wand was, as is demonstrated in GoF. If Albus has two wands, he's spent 20 years being too scared to cast reverse spell on his other wand, which seems somewhat out of character.

  • Albatross
    Albatross 3 أشهر قبل

    does the wand understand the language ? What happen if a wand only understood english and is used by a wizard who speaks only spanish?

    IGGY ISLA 3 أشهر قبل

    because they in looooove

  • gryffondor and hufflepuff bois reacy gryffindor

    I think it's because the Dumbledore is in love with Grindelwald himself

  • gryffondor and hufflepuff bois reacy gryffindor

    I wonder what would have happened if Dumbledore did move against Grindelwald instead of scamander probably would have gotten the Elder Wand before

  • Vandana Gaur
    Vandana Gaur 3 أشهر قبل

    Maybe they made an unbreakable val

  • Dumb RedNeck
    Dumb RedNeck 3 أشهر قبل

    Also albus is also gay jk also said that is true

  • Dumb RedNeck
    Dumb RedNeck 3 أشهر قبل

    Ok the elder wand was made by itself as of the deathly hollos so if it had a brother wouldn't it be 4 deathly hollos

  • Luna Nyx Nightshade
    Luna Nyx Nightshade 3 أشهر قبل

    Dumbledore and grindelwald made a promise not to hurt each other that is why he can't stop grindelwald

  • l-i-h
    l-i-h 3 أشهر قبل

    Jesus christ the intro was soo unnecessarily loud and annoying heyyyyykfjfnnfndndb jdjdbfb

  • Red Ostrich
    Red Ostrich 3 أشهر قبل

    Tom Riddled with mysteries? That is a very good Joke Rowling (Get it because JK stands for joke? No? I will just leave then.)

  • senad bibanović
    senad bibanović 3 أشهر قبل

    Actually he cannot go fight Gellert because they have a blood pact that says that they cannot fight each other

  • M ter Haar
    M ter Haar 3 أشهر قبل

    Didn't bellatrix also use priori incantatem on Hermoine's wand? How did that work than?

  • Sarah Castille
    Sarah Castille 3 أشهر قبل +1

    If Dumbledore is over 100 when he dies then how old is he in this movie?

  • Anton Kann
    Anton Kann 3 أشهر قبل

    I do not know if anyone else has written this, but the mainreason that Dumbledore does not want to face Grindelwald is because they are not able to harm each other because they made an unbreakable vow. So if one of them try to harm the other, he will die. And if the elderwand somehow would have a brother why is it not one of the deathly hallows??

  • Shanaya prem
    Shanaya prem 3 أشهر قبل +1

    Dumbledor is gay and they made a blood pact when they were dating

  • Draco Lucius Malfoy
    Draco Lucius Malfoy 3 أشهر قبل

    Can I just say that Dumbledore can't move against Grindlewald because when they were kids they made a unbreakable vow that they can't harm each other or something in between those lines so Dumbledore can't act against him.

  • Calming Tomatoes
    Calming Tomatoes 3 أشهر قبل +1

    He couldn’t because he made a unbreakable promise