Shutter Island: Is It Deep or Dumb? (Leonardo DiCaprio) - Wisecrack Edition

مشاركة
تضمين
  • تم نشره في 2019/10/19
  • Get started with 8 free meals - that’s $80 off your first month of HelloFresh. Go to bit.ly/31d8lnH and enter WC80.
    Thanks to HelloFresh for sponsoring this video!

    Subscribe to Wisecrack! ► wscrk.com/SbscrbWC
    Join WisecrackPLUS for EXCLUSIVE content! ► wscrk.com/YtWcPls
    Shutter Island is an indisputably mind-bending film with plenty of twists and turns. Provocative and divisive, this Martin Scorcese thriller has been criticized for being too predictable or having too many plot holes. But is there something more profound going on in the neo-noir flick? Let’s find out in this Wisecrack Edition on Shutter Island: Deep or Dumb?

    === Watch More Episodes! ===
    SOUTH PARK on Freedom ► wscrk.com/2OZN5PD
    SPIDER-MAN: FAR FROM HOME: A New Philosophy for Marvel ► wscrk.com/31lwj0c
    JOKER and The Quest for Recognition ► wscrk.com/2B4wvpW
    DOCUMENTARIES vs. REALITY TV: How They Shape Truth ► wscrk.com/333gYm6
    The (Possible) Philosophy of THOR: Love and Thunder ► wscrk.com/2nhAWdw
    Why Outrage rules ARclip & The INTERNET ► wscrk.com/2nkxTRm


    Store ........... wisecrack.store/
    Twitter ......... wisecrack
    Facebook .... wisecrackedu

    Written by: Amanda Scherker
    Directed by: Elizabeth Yarwood
    Hosted by: Helen Floersh
    Editing by: Andrew Nishimura
    Produced by: Evan Yee

    © 2019 Wisecrack / Omnia Media, Inc.

تعليقات • 645

  • Nicanor Núñez
    Nicanor Núñez 2 ساعات قبل

    Yey Hellen!

  • Farbod Pirouz
    Farbod Pirouz أيام قبل

    Are we sure he never read Arkham Asylum?

  • Cris Haas
    Cris Haas 3 أيام قبل

    Dumb and Dumber, deep or dumb?

  • Jason Santos
    Jason Santos 5 أيام قبل

    Shutter Island has some deep dating that's why I like about the film he probably did it on purpose to get him the Bonnie Lies he doesn't want to look at memories anymore

  • A Zaga
    A Zaga 11 أيام قبل +1

    More like "Shitter Island"

  • James Foley
    James Foley 13 أيام قبل

    Love the new look, Jared.

  • Blaze_5
    Blaze_5 13 أيام قبل

    i am not over exaggerating but i think 60% of the movie came out from a videogame called the suffering that was released 2004 you should check it out

  • Uremawife Nowdave
    Uremawife Nowdave 13 أيام قبل +1

    2:57 guys, 2:57.

  • Marco Klaue
    Marco Klaue 14 أيام قبل

    I realize you couldn't make a comprehensive list of all the shout-outs here -- Hitchcock, noir, Kubrick, etc., -- but no mention of German Expressionism? I mean, "Shutter Island" is basically a remake of "The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari"...
    (Oh yeah: spoilers for a silent film from a century ago)

  • Matthew Rodriguez
    Matthew Rodriguez 14 أيام قبل

    Can you do “the cell” deep or dumb!

  • Marill Sweatshirt
    Marill Sweatshirt 15 أيام قبل

    It's dumb, but I still love this movie.🤷🏿‍♂️

  • Wesdon
    Wesdon 16 أيام قبل

    Do philosophy of wall-e

  • Lorn M
    Lorn M 16 أيام قبل

    Why don't you get we love jared's boring voice

  • syko banana
    syko banana 16 أيام قبل +2

    Let me save you time... the movie's well made and acted, but the "twist" can be seen miles way and the plot is totally implausable.

  • alex chalakee
    alex chalakee 16 أيام قبل

    "Shutter Island is deep". I'd say it's deeper than The Room.

  • jv7x
    jv7x 17 أيام قبل

    All that is well and good but if it fails to make sense or entertain then it's Dumb. Hey Scorcese, maybe you could learn a thing or two from watching a Marvel movie.

  • Agent Smith 18
    Agent Smith 18 17 أيام قبل

    had to watch the movie so i can watch this

  • Silkroadgermany2
    Silkroadgermany2 17 أيام قبل

    What could *possibly* be dumb about Shutter Island? Though I love Wisecrack, I really don't appreciate the clickbaity/ degrading title.

  • Evan Payne
    Evan Payne 17 أيام قبل

    You can yell deeper, but 3 inches is 3 inches.

  • drghaam hussain
    drghaam hussain 17 أيام قبل

    Where is Jared, and why there is no music?

  • Javier Cáceres Molina
    Javier Cáceres Molina 18 أيام قبل

    Silent Hill 2 ruined Shutter Island for me. I worked out the ending in about 20 minutes. First clue? The main character washing his face and looking into the mirror trying to figure out if what he was living was real.

  • MegaRudeBoy69
    MegaRudeBoy69 18 أيام قبل

    I think of it as one of those Joseph Beuys peices of art, it has to be explained to be understood or appreciated. Personally i'm not a fan of work that doesn't speak for itself. Now that Emma Watson broke it down, i can see what Scorsese was aiming for, but my mind isn't blown.

  • sidgeaberration
    sidgeaberration 18 أيام قبل

    Me about 5 minutes in: works out the twist.
    Me about 6 minutes in: nah it can't be, it's too obvious.
    The end of the movie: yeah that was it.

  • Evil Paragon 4
    Evil Paragon 4 18 أيام قبل

    I didn't know there were people out there who would call this movie Dumb.

  • The Storytellers
    The Storytellers 18 أيام قبل

    I like what you do on this channel, but if you take a deep dive into this film, you'd be remiss not mention the 2003 novel by Dennis Lehane. The book is excellent and Martin's film is as close to a direct adaptation as one could hope, probably one of the most faithful adaptations cinema has to offer. All the gothic moodiness and Noir themes are pulled directly from the page, almost as if they used the novel as a shooting script. A thrilling read even when you already know the ending and without which, the movie would not exist.

  • Corvax
    Corvax 18 أيام قبل

    I'd love to see y'all do an episode on "funny games" the entire movie is a metacommentary on the horror genre and is intentionally written and edited to infuriate the viewer.

  • Max Covfefe
    Max Covfefe 19 أيام قبل

    The trailers ruined this movie. I didn't see it for that reason.

  • Tanner Davis
    Tanner Davis 19 أيام قبل +1

    Do a Deep or Dumb on the Eric Andrea Show!!

  • Ncb Engineering
    Ncb Engineering 19 أيام قبل

    I anticipate I’ll get a lot of shit for throwing this out there, but I’m interested on your deep or dumb take on “Mr. Nobody”
    * immediately deploys barrier rendering all witticisms about pseudo existentialist self indulgence innocuous*
    HA! Bet y’all didn’t see that coming, now I’m invincible

  • The Wandering Aristotle
    The Wandering Aristotle 19 أيام قبل

    There's nothing like Marty.

  • Junk Owl
    Junk Owl 19 أيام قبل

    What's that movie where the man goes inside the toilet

  • trapez77
    trapez77 20 أيام قبل

    Wisecrack should do a video about the misconception of colors. And how red yellow green and blue are the real primary colors of life. And not just RGB or RYB or CMYK. Blue is closest to black and yellow is closest to white. And red and green are in the middle near mid-grey. Things get complicated when you start thinking about warm/cool colors though. Yellow-green and magenta are the only 2 colors that are neutral warm/cool.

  • Taste Sking
    Taste Sking 20 أيام قبل

    wisecrack hosts look dead inside. especially when performing sponsors.

  • xcaluhbration
    xcaluhbration 20 أيام قبل

    That might've been...
    The LONGEST ADVERTISEMENT I've seen on this channel YET!

  • Matthew Shreve
    Matthew Shreve 20 أيام قبل

    In the face of making the mistake that is “posting an opinion on the Internet,” I have to hard disagree on this one.

  • anthony gutierrez
    anthony gutierrez 20 أيام قبل

    id hit

  • Ci Wa
    Ci Wa 20 أيام قبل

    Does anyone know the background track/music playing during this video? I really like the way it sounds and would like to download it. The track I want starts @ 12:30.

  • Antonio Hugo
    Antonio Hugo 20 أيام قبل

    0:29 which movie is this one?

  • Ali Shughait
    Ali Shughait 20 أيام قبل

    Shutter Island is a masterpiece and Leo was as always outstanding

  • mariam al said
    mariam al said 20 أيام قبل

    If u want to claim that the story doesn’t add up, don’t just skip over that sentence and consider it a fact. Support ur argument 😤😒

  • DRUNK SHEEP
    DRUNK SHEEP 20 أيام قبل

    This film is awesome. I dont see a reason why it should be "deep or dumb" since the answer is obvious.

  • ann/drew g
    ann/drew g 20 أيام قبل

    Can yall do ‘synecdoche new york’

  • The man to scared to get a tattoo

    Shutter Island is like a less good inception.

  • mrmathman202
    mrmathman202 20 أيام قبل

    I still believe that it wasn’t all in his mind because that ending would honestly be way cooler

  • The man to scared to get a tattoo

    I like your face, you got a good face on ya.

  • lfutrell82
    lfutrell82 20 أيام قبل

    I really liked this movie. The first time I saw it, I immediately watched it again because I was confused 🙃

  • Gustavo Marquez
    Gustavo Marquez 21 أيام قبل

    Wisecrack!! Hope someday you could make a video on the current situation on southamerica. Or maybe a podcast (cultural binge)? It is interesting how countries are divided by half now. And populism is spreading througout the world. Greetings from Bolivia!!!

  • RedboRF
    RedboRF 21 أيام قبل

    The most underrated Scorsese's films, make no mistake about it.

  • Michael Healy
    Michael Healy 21 أيام قبل

    So he really is an insane person who doctors played a big therapy game with?

  • Michael McCaffrey
    Michael McCaffrey 21 أيام قبل

    I don't like when they don't say if its deep or dumb. My opinions need to be spoon fed to me

  • Michael Healy
    Michael Healy 21 أيام قبل

    If it's not Jared I don't watch! Sorry Jamie, or was it Jessica?

  • LeBaron Co.
    LeBaron Co. 21 أيام قبل +1

    1: ad at the beginning was waaaaay to long guys come on now.
    2: where's Jared?
    3: Ma'am you're trying to hard. It feels like you are forcing me to listen to an English 1 essay that you crammed with filler to meet the assignments recommended word count.

  • Ethos711
    Ethos711 21 أيام قبل

    I liked the film will enough by the end, but the editing felt so amateurish in the beginning that I really struggled to get into the movie. There was a period where I was wondering what moron did the editing before I came to realize it was intentional. I imagine it would work better on subsequent viewings.

  • Jack Thomas
    Jack Thomas 21 أيام قبل

    Why her neck look 10 years older than her face

  • Mike Scott
    Mike Scott 21 أيام قبل

    Unfortunately for me, this particular film telegraphed too much and I saw the ending coming a mile away. So much in fact that I fell asleep in theaters watching it and woke up around the last 20 minutes to tell my friend sitting next to me “told ya”. This isn’t a jab at Scorsese; I just don’t think it was in his top films. Of course, that’s just my opinion though.

  • IvoryweedsPGH
    IvoryweedsPGH 21 أيام قبل

    TOO MANY ADS!!!!

  • Peter Glagowski
    Peter Glagowski 21 أيام قبل

    I honestly didn't like the film all that much because it pays so much homage to the past. It doesn't feel original, even if the story ultimately has a well-thought-out message.

  • Michael Monzon
    Michael Monzon 21 أيام قبل

    How long is your goddamn comercial????

  • VicInNocal
    VicInNocal 21 أيام قبل

    Probably my favorite Scorsese movie, and it is one that is kinda under-the-radar. Not a fan of Taxi Driver, Raging Bull, or Casino, and I think the Departed is shockingly overrated (just another cop movie, and it wasn't even an original but a remake of a movie that had come out recently). I liked The Aviator, Goodfellas too.

  • JohnBoy
    JohnBoy 21 أيام قبل

    Helen's a great host!